Review: Milk and Cookies Ice Cream and Cookies

Hey Mesa Nation and welcome back to this week’s article on The Hitching Post. This weekend, Hunter, Vince and I decided to try Milk and Cookies, and review their flavor for you. Milk and Cookies Ice Cream and Cookies is a great place to visit when craving more than just a simple sweet treat. From different ice cream flavors and several cookie options to choose from, the combinations are endless. The combinations we tried were a chocolate chip cookie and vanilla ice cream, a smores cookie and Cookie Monster ice cream, and a Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup cookie with chocolate ice cream.

Chocolate Chip Cookie and Vanilla Ice Cream

Chloe: This was probably the most classic combination we tried, but still tasted really good. I liked the softness of the chocolate chip cookie paired with the fresh vanilla flavoring in the ice cream.

Vince: I agree that the cookie tasted fresh, but in my opinion I feel like the combination could use a little more chocolate. It was still pretty good, but chocolate chip ice cream would’ve bumped up my rating.

Hunter: Out of all three combinations this is probably my least favorite. I feel as though it’s too simple, and lacks a lot of flavor, it’s just too bland.

Smores Cookie and Cookie Monster Ice Cream

Chloe: This one is my go to order and is so nostalgic to me. I love the cookie monster ice cream as the cookie dough comes through so well. I also love their smores cookie, its just the right amount of chocolate and marshmallow with a hint of graham cracker that really does it for me.

Vince: Since I love chocolate this is probably the winner for me, it’s just so rich which I love. The ice cream is very sweet too making it all come together. I also agree with Chloe that this cookie is very good, and I would honestly get by itself.

Hunter: This one is not my favorite, in my opinion it’s too sweet. I feel as though cookie monster and smores don’t belong together, and it kind of just throws off the whole flavoring for me.

Lastly we revied the:

Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Cookie with Chocolate Ice Cream

Chloe: I didn’t really like this one. I felt as if there was too much chocolate which is surprising as I love chocolate. There just wasn’t enough peanut butter for this combination.

Vince: Again, I agree with Chloe, just way too much chocolate. The peanut butter just doesn’t come through and really lacks.

Hunter: This one really isn’t good, like the both of them said, too much chocolate. I like the cookie by itself a lot as well as the ice cream. It’s really rich, however, together is not the combo I like.

Overall, we rate Milk and Cookies itself a 8/10. We feel as though now that we’ve been we know what combinations to get. However, we do believe that the cookies are better than the ice cream for those interested in trying. Let us know what you think when trying Milk and Cookies, and give us new orders to try!

Author